Golden Grilled Turkey Reuben

Craving a classic deli sandwich but looking for a fresh, lighter take? The **Rachel sandwich**, often hailed as the grilled turkey Reuben’s delightful cousin, offers all the comforting flavors you love in a traditional Reuben, but with a unique twist. This mouth-watering sandwich is a perfect choice for those seeking easy lunch recipes, quick dinner ideas, or even exciting family meal options that cater to diverse palates.

What truly distinguishes the Rachel sandwich is its brilliant substitution of tender, sliced turkey for the customary corned beef. This simple change transforms the hearty Reuben into a more health-conscious yet equally satisfying meal. Layered with tangy sauerkraut (or crisp coleslaw for an even lighter touch), creamy Swiss cheese, and the unmistakable zest of Thousand Island dressing, all nestled between slices of robust rye bread and grilled to golden-brown perfection, the Rachel sandwich delivers an exquisite harmony of tastes and textures. It’s a culinary masterpiece that promises a delightful blend of savory, sour, and rich notes in every bite.

Whether you’re planning a casual game day spread, searching for quick and healthy lunch alternatives, or aiming to please even the pickiest eaters with kid-friendly meals, this homemade grilled turkey Reuben rises to the occasion. Its versatility and irresistible flavor profile make it a beloved choice for any time of the day.

Essential Ingredients for Your Perfect Rachel Sandwich

Crafting the perfect Rachel sandwich, also known as a grilled turkey Reuben, relies on a handful of high-quality ingredients that harmonize to create its distinctive flavor. While the ingredient list is straightforward, each component plays a crucial role in achieving that irresistible balance of savory, tangy, and creamy. Here’s a closer look at what you’ll need to assemble this delightful sandwich:

• Deli-Sliced Turkey: The star of the show. Opt for high-quality, thinly sliced turkey breast. Oven-roasted or smoked turkey varieties work wonderfully, offering a rich, savory base that stands up to the other bold flavors. Aim for a generous portion, typically around 5 ounces per sandwich, to ensure a satisfying bite.
• Rye Bread: The foundation of any great Reuben or Rachel. Marble rye is a popular choice for its beautiful swirl and mild rye flavor, but pumpernickel or even a classic light rye will also deliver that essential hearty texture and taste. The bread needs to be sturdy enough to hold the fillings and toast beautifully on the griddle.
• Swiss Cheese: Known for its distinctive nutty flavor and excellent melting properties, Swiss cheese is a non-negotiable component. It creates a gooey, savory layer that binds the sandwich together and adds a wonderful creaminess. Provolone or Gruyere could be considered for a slight variation, but Swiss is truly traditional.
• Sauerkraut or Coleslaw: This is where the Rachel offers its main point of divergence and customization.
  • Sauerkraut: For a flavor profile most akin to its Reuben cousin, use well-drained sauerkraut. Its fermented tang adds a sharp, briny counterpoint to the rich turkey and cheese.
  • Coleslaw: If you prefer a milder, sweeter, and even lighter option, creamy coleslaw is an excellent substitution. Its crunch and slight sweetness beautifully complement the other ingredients, creating a different but equally delicious experience. Ensure it’s not overly watery.
• Thousand Island Dressing: This creamy, tangy, and slightly sweet dressing is essential for binding all the flavors. Its distinctive blend of mayonnaise, ketchup (or chili sauce), and relish provides the perfect zing. While some purists argue for Russian dressing (which typically has horseradish or hot sauce), Thousand Island is widely accepted and loved in Rachel sandwiches.
• Butter: Crucial for grilling the bread to a perfectly golden, crispy exterior. Softened butter ensures an even spread and facilitates that desirable rich, buttery crust.

Before you begin assembling, remember to check your ingredients. Ensuring your sauerkraut is well-drained and your turkey is briefly warmed will significantly enhance the final product. Quality ingredients make all the difference in achieving a truly exceptional homemade Rachel sandwich.

Creative Variations and Delightful Substitutions for Your Rachel Sandwich

The Rachel sandwich itself is a beloved variation of the classic Reuben, ingeniously swapping corned beef for turkey. However, the beauty of this sandwich lies in its flexibility, allowing for further customization to suit individual preferences. Exploring these variations can transform your Rachel sandwich into a truly personalized culinary creation.

The most common and impactful substitution revolves around the pickled vegetable component, offering distinct flavor profiles:

• Sauerkraut (Traditional Rachel): To keep your Rachel most similar to its Reuben origins, stick with tangy, well-drained sauerkraut. Its fermented, briny notes cut through the richness of the cheese and turkey, providing that classic deli zest.
• Coleslaw (Lighter and Sweeter): For an even lighter, creamier, and slightly sweeter sandwich, coleslaw is an excellent alternative. The crispness of the cabbage and the creamy dressing add a refreshing contrast. Many find this option incredibly delicious, offering a less intense tang than sauerkraut. If using store-bought coleslaw, ensure it’s not overly watery; homemade coleslaw allows for better moisture control and flavor customization.

Another point of delightful debate and customization involves the dressing:

• Thousand Island Dressing (Popular Choice): This dressing, with its creamy, sweet, and tangy profile, is widely used in Rachel sandwiches and is often my go-to. Its harmonious blend complements all the other ingredients beautifully.
• Russian Dressing (For a Spicier Kick): Some sandwich aficionados argue that a true Rachel should feature Russian dressing, which typically includes horseradish or chili sauce, giving it a spicier, more robust flavor. If you enjoy a bit of heat and a bolder, more savory profile, give Russian dressing a try.

Having experimented with all these combinations, I often find myself returning to my personal favorite: a Rachel sandwich built with tender turkey, crisp coleslaw, and a generous slather of Thousand Island dressing. The blend of textures and the slightly sweet, tangy creaminess is simply irresistible. However, my partner prefers the classic tang of sauerkraut in his sandwich, proving that personal taste is paramount. The beauty of the Rachel sandwich is that you can customize it precisely to your liking, creating your perfect version every time!

Beyond these classic variations, feel free to get creative:

• Cheese Alternatives: While Swiss is traditional, try provolone for a sharper flavor or even a mild cheddar for a different texture.
• Bread Choices: Explore different types of rye, like a darker pumpernickel, or even a good sourdough for a distinct tang.
• Add-ins: Consider adding a slice of tomato or a few dill pickle chips for extra freshness and crunch within the sandwich.

The Rachel sandwich is a canvas for your creativity, inviting you to experiment and discover your ideal combination of flavors and textures.

Step-by-Step Guide: Crafting Your Perfect Rachel Sandwich (Grilled Turkey Reuben)

Making a delicious Rachel sandwich is surprisingly simple, requiring minimal prep and yielding maximum flavor. Follow these straightforward steps to create a perfectly grilled, wonderfully melty, and utterly satisfying turkey Reuben right in your own kitchen.

1. Prepare Your Fillings

The first step is to ensure your fillings are ready for assembly. If you’re using sauerkraut, it’s crucial to drain it thoroughly to prevent a soggy sandwich. Simply place it in a colander and press out any excess liquid. If your coleslaw seems overly juicy, a similar draining step can be beneficial, though homemade coleslaw often allows for better moisture control from the start. For my homemade coleslaw, I manage the dressing to avoid this issue.

Once drained, I like to give both the deli-sliced turkey and the sauerkraut a quick zap in the microwave for about 30 seconds. This step takes the chill off, ensuring the sandwich heats evenly and the cheese melts more efficiently when grilled. Remember, skip this warming step if you’re using coleslaw, as it’s best served chilled or at room temperature.

2. Assemble Your Sandwich Layers

Now, it’s time to build your masterpiece. Lay out two slices of your chosen rye bread on a clean work surface. My preferred method is to start with a slice of Swiss cheese directly on one piece of bread. This strategic placement ensures the cheese is closest to the heat source on the griddle, guaranteeing that it becomes beautifully gooey and melted. A perfectly melted cheese is key to a truly indulgent Rachel.

Next, pile a generous amount of your warmed, deli-sliced turkey (approximately 5 ounces) on top of the Swiss cheese. On the other slice of rye bread, spread a liberal layer of Thousand Island (or Russian) dressing. This ensures every bite is infused with that signature tangy-sweet flavor.

Finally, top the turkey with your choice of sauerkraut or coleslaw. You’ll need about ¼ to ½ cup for each sandwich, depending on your preference. I typically add the coleslaw directly onto the turkey layer. This clever trick allows me to easily flip the dressing-coated slice of bread on top without any coleslaw spilling out, keeping everything neat and tidy.

3. Butter and Grill to Perfection

Before introducing your sandwich to the heat, generously butter one side of the assembled sandwich. A good layer of softened butter is crucial for achieving that desirable golden-brown, crispy crust. Don’t be shy here; butter is flavor and texture!

Heat your griddle, grill pan, or skillet over medium heat. Once hot, carefully place the buttered side of the sandwich down onto the cooking surface. As the first side begins to sizzle and toast, generously butter the other exposed side of the bread. This ensures both sides will achieve that perfect crispy texture.

Cook the sandwich for approximately 2 to 3 minutes per side. You’re looking for a beautifully golden-brown crust and for the Swiss cheese to be completely melted and gooey. The internal fillings should also be warmed through. Keep an eye on the heat to prevent burning; adjust as necessary.

Once both sides are perfectly toasted and the cheese is melted, remove the sandwich from the griddle. For easier eating and a classic deli presentation, slice the sandwich in half diagonally. This reveals all the glorious layers within.

The result is a sandwich that is creamy, crunchy, delightfully savory, and utterly irresistible. It’s a true celebration of textures and flavors that will leave you craving more!

Perfect Pairings: What to Serve with Your Rachel Sandwich

The Rachel sandwich, much like its Reuben counterpart, evokes the comforting, hearty feel of classic “bar food” or a beloved deli staple. This grilled turkey Reuben is substantial enough to stand alone, but pairing it with the right side dishes can elevate your meal into a truly satisfying experience. Embrace the spirit of casual dining with these delicious serving suggestions:

• Crispy Fries: There’s almost nothing more iconic than a hot, crispy side of French fries alongside a grilled sandwich. The salty crunch perfectly contrasts the rich, gooey Rachel. For a twist, consider serving with sweet potato fries, which offer a hint of sweetness and a different textural dimension.
• Dill Pickle Spear: A crisp dill pickle spear is a refreshing and traditional accompaniment that cuts through the richness of the sandwich with its sharp, briny flavor. It’s a simple addition that makes a big impact.
• Green Salad: For a lighter meal, a fresh side salad with a simple vinaigrette can provide a healthy balance and a burst of freshness. Think mixed greens, cherry tomatoes, and cucumber.
• Potato Chips: A classic, no-fuss option. A handful of your favorite potato chips, whether plain, salt & vinegar, or barbecue flavored, adds an easy crunch.
• Soup: During cooler months, pairing your Rachel with a warm bowl of tomato soup, creamy potato soup, or a hearty vegetable soup creates an ultimate comfort food combo. The “sandwich and soup” duo is always a winner.
• Extra Thousand Island Dressing: Don’t forget to offer a small side dish of extra Thousand Island dressing. It makes a fantastic dipping sauce for both the sandwich and any accompanying fries, adding an extra layer of creamy, tangy goodness.

Whether you’re recreating a deli experience at home or simply looking for an easy yet satisfying meal, these serving suggestions will complete your Rachel sandwich feast, making it truly memorable.

5 from 23 votes

Print
Pin it!

Rachel Sandwich (Grilled Turkey Reuben)

Nutrition values are estimates only, using online calculators. Please verify using your own data.